Travelling Music: Johnny B. Goode, Johnny B. Gone

[Sign up today for Not The Public Broadcaster newsletters. Hot takes and cool slants on sports and current affairs. Have the latest columns delivered to your mail box. Tell your friends to join, too. Always provocative, always independent.  ] 

“And that’s the news for now, I’ll be back here at 11, unless a news station in Columbus offers me way less money… and I’ll probably go do that.—Calgary CBC TV anchor Andrew Brown

Hard to imagine. A player whose brilliant OT goal that won the Calgary Flames their first-round playoff series could go from rapturous applause to pariah status in eight weeks. But that is the saga of Johnny Gaudreau. “Johnny Hockey” is now Dear John in eyes of Flames fans who worshipped him so recently. 

His heel turn in cooly rejecting those fans— “we were super excited with being able to sign here in Columbus”— has also created a firestorm in the media about homerism and Canada/ U.S. hockey sensitivities. 

The story: The diminutive Gaudreau was a fourth-round Calgary draft pick who debuted in 2013. Deft with slick hands he was the team’s best offensive player since Jarome Iginla. He was also prone to disappearing on the ice, especially in big games. A 36-goal season in 2018-19 was followed by years of 18 then 19 goals. 

After scoring four goals in his first playoff year 2014-15 Gaudreau posted just four more playoff goals before this year. This antagonized Flames fans who periodically demanded he be traded for a bigger, more impactful player. There were frequent “Johnny Party” sightings in clubs and bars around town. He was the second coming of Dion Phaneuf as he enjoyed himself liberally.

The Flames were vexed, and, as the 29-year-old Gaudreau entered the final year of a contract, they were taking a wait-and-see approach. Gaudreau, a child of Canadian parents who grew up in New Jersey, bet on himself. They’d see what happened.

What happened was one of the greatest contract years ever in sports, when an pending free agent exceeds expectations by such levels that he puts himself at the very pinnacle of the pay scale. Gaudreau scored 40 goals with 115 points, thrusting himself into Hart Trophy candidacy. His 5-on-5 numbers led the NHL by a mile. His linemates fed off him, both scoring 42 goals themselves. The Flames won the Pacific Division.

In the opening series against hot Dallas goalie, Gaudreau provided the clincher with sensational shoreside top corner laser. Public opinion was now all for giving Gaudreau a max contract offer. The team made noises about doing just that to keep their franchise payer. But Gaudreau wasn’t buying. Maybe winning the Western Conference or the Stanley Cup could change things.

No one told Connor McDavid and the bitter provincial rivals from Edmonton. Even with goalie Mike Smith’s blunders, the Oilers systematically destroyed Calgary in five games. The Flames’ top line disappeared. Begging the question, would Gaudreau disappear permanently?

For a small Canadian city, the idea of not being able to hang onto their stars is existential. Edmonton has spent a king’s ransom to keep McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and Ryan Nugent Hopkins from skipping town. Coming on the heels of Calgary’s arena project collapsing, losing Gaudreau would be a gut punch to civic pride. 

When news came that a now-married Gaudreau, awaiting the birth of his first child, wanted to be closer to home in New Jersey fans gulped. They’d seen the Gaudreau clan in the playoffs celebrating with him. They appeared tight-knit,. Who could compete with that? All the Flames could do was offer the most money.

Which they did. So imagine the saltiness of Calgary fans when, after leading the Flames management right to the final night before free agency they learned he was going nowhere near the east coast. He was going to the Columbus, Ohio— in the Midwest— for millions less than he’d have made in Alberta. To a team that’s as close to the bottom of the NHL as to the top.

Eric Duhatschek summed it the stunned reaction in The Athletic, “The fact that it took Gaudreau so long to choose effectively sabotaged the Flames’ off-season, because it closed so many possible Plan B options to the organization. Closer to home, but not close — because if close to home was the absolute priority, then he could have picked the New Jersey Devils, who also tabled an offer. 

Columbus is more easily reached by private jet than Calgary, but it’s not as if he’ll be dropping into his mom’s house for dinner after a game or a practice — or getting emergency babysitting service if they need someone right this minute to help out on the home front.”

Other comments took a similar tack. No one begrudged the family angle, but when Gaudreau told Columbus media, “it didn’t matter where i was signing. Our decision was it was best for us not to go back to Calgary,” the divorce got nasty. 

And so did the media sniping. In the New York Post Larry Brooks sneered, “The hysterical response to Johnny Gaudreau’s decision to leave millions on the table in Calgary and instead sign with Columbus was indeed just that. Players are routinely lambasted across the professional sports landscape for being greedy mercenaries. Now this one is being targeted for taking a road less traveled.”

On Barstool Sports, someone called The Rear Admiral summed up a scathing putdown with “Hell hath no fury like Canadian media (allegedly) scorned.” And those were the printable comments. “But when media members wail and stomp their feet because a fellow adult opts to work in a new location, well that's a special kind of entertainment.”

What will the Flames do to replace Gaudreau at the last minute in free agency? Should they now dump his $9 million ex-linemate Matthew Tkachuk, too, and start a rebuild? The Flames (who wished him well publicly) are boxed in. The only certainty is that the hottest ticket of the season will be January 23 when Columbus visits Calgary. Don’t expect a love-in. 

Bruce Dowbiggin @dowbboy is the editor of Not The Public Broadcaster . A two-time winner of the Gemini Award as Canada's top television sports broadcaster, he’s a regular contributor to Sirius XM Canada Talks Ch. 167. Inexact Science: The Six Most Compelling Draft YearsIn NHL History, , his new book written with his son Evan, has been selected the eighth-best professional hockey book of all time by bookauthority.org . His 2004 book Money Players was voted seventh best, and is available via http://brucedowbigginbooks.ca/book-personalaccount.aspx